3-030 | Additional Comments | Previous Article | Next Article | List of Articles | Submit Comments | Index | FSN Home Page
Oversupply of Neonatologists 2
Is More Neonatal Intensive Care Always Better? Insights From a Cross-National Comparison of Reproductive Care. Thompson LA, Goodman DC, and Little GA. PEDIATRICS (June 2002) 206:1036-1043.
Objective.
To characterize systems of reproductive care for the United States, Australia, Canada, and the United Kingdom, including a detailed analysis of neonatal intensive care and mortality.Results. Compared with the other 3 countries, the United States has more neonatal intensive care resources yet provides proportionately less support for preconception and prenatal care. Unlike the United States, the other countries provided free family planning services and prenatal and perinatal physician care, and the United Kingdom and Australia paid for all contraception. The United States has high neonatal intensive care capacity, with 6.1 neonatologists per 10,000 live births; Australia, 3.7; Canada, 3.3; and the United Kingdom, 2.7. For intensive care beds, the United States has 3.3 per 10,000 live births; Australia and Canada, 2.6; and the United Kingdom, 0.67. Greater neonatal intensive care resources were not consistently associated with lower birth weight-specific mortality. The relative risk (United States as reference) of neonatal mortality for infants <1000 g was 0.84 for Australia, 1.12 for Canada, and 0.99 for the United Kingdom; for 1000 to 2499 g infants, the relative risk was 0.97 for Australia, 1.26 for Canada, and 0.95 for the United Kingdom. As reported elsewhere, low birth weight rates were notably higher in the United States, partially explaining the high crude mortality rates.
Comment. The theme of this article and the previous one (3-029) are the same: more neonatologists and NICU beds does not translate into improved neonatal survival rates. The key to success may be more funding for prenatal care initiatives. ABK
Additional Comments: You may add your own comments to the discussion of this topic by selecting : Submit Comments.